
"You haven't the slightest proof of anything"...."But I have my certainty."
"Doubt," starring Philip Seymour Hoffman and Meryl Streep, was remarkable. Both actors brought stellar performances to the table in a highly charged drama about the search for truth, and standing up for that which you believe to be true. The story unfolds around the passing observation of a somewhat peculiar incident involving Father Flynn, fueling suspicion and rage within the headmistress Sister Beauvier, and ultimately doubt in his defense. Through volatile and impassioned dialogue, we come to understand how powerful a conviction can be, particularly in the absence of evidence. The beauty of this movie is that we never really know if Father Flynn committed a crime. This, in my view, is not the point of the movie, but rather, how we arrive at such an accusation. Is instinct enough, or is proof necessary? Does it matter if others believe you, or is your own personal persuasion enough?
The scenes develop amidst the backdrop of various issues that defined the 1960's Catholic church: gender inequality between the priesthood and sisterhood; the role of the church within the student's (and family's) life; and in general, conservative versus progressive values. Ideologically, Sister Beauvier and Father Flynn each want to lead the church in a different direction, and this is the foundation that allows a simple suspicion to quickly become a life-changing allegation. Ultimately we are forced to question whether Sister Beauvier is acting on her own behalf or on that of the church.
Both actors do a phenomenal job of delivering profound and convincing performances, with a tang of humor. Expect an Academy Award or two from this movie.




